From Brokeback to Obergefell

Twelve years. Ten years. Two years. Thirteen months. And six months. This is the timeline–a narrative–of a movement, of a man, of a love story still being written.

I was thirteen going on fourteen when Lawrence v. Texas came down. I was a year past my Bar Mitzvah, saw no place for myself in Judaism anymore. On the one hand I felt I had learned everything the faith could teach me; on the other I was realizing I didn’t belong. The Supreme Court’s decision must’ve been in the news. I know now the striking-down of anti-sodomy laws was the first earthquake in a series of many since the turn of the century that brought forth the fire and brimstone of unadulterated Christian hatred, but back then, struggling to accept my fluid beliefs, my sexuality and how others saw it wasn’t in mind.

That year, 2003, rolled away with a breakdown of marriage–before 2004 was up, my parents had separated, divorce papers filed after a year and a day, and my siblings and mother had moved into a just-almost-too-small duplex in Public Housing where we’ve been since, every sound carried no matter how close to silent it might be.

Ten years ago I turned sixteen. It was the summer of hype and horror stories over Brokeback Mountain making its way through theaters. I’d only ever heard of gay people on TV a few times before. Once the news said some disease was more common among gay men, but before the story was up, my parents interrupted dinner to turn the TV off. Two other times TV shows we watched regularly had a gay or lesbian character on ’em, and my parents said we wouldn’t watch those episodes. Naturally, in secret, I went back and watched both of them, never knowing how much those shows being pushed out of sight would make me push myself out of sight when my own turn came to be censored.

I’d be lying to say I didn’t know by then I was attracted to men. While my mom worked in the kitchen at my synagogue, before I even turned twelve, I’d lie down in boredom, close my eyes, and imagine riding shirtless down a highway in the passenger seat of a red topless Lamborghini. The bright sun turned to salty condensation down the driver’s chiseled chest, he looked at me through his sunglasses, I melted back into the seat.

For a time I convinced myself it was only a higher strain of existence: the Greeks, after all, had prized male beauty above all else, and hardly that was a bad thing, right? Except all my dreams of marrying my best friend at the time ended with her and me being divorced, me a single dad, and then in a strange sort of inversion because my mind didn’t know how else it could happen, my son was my age and we were raising other kids together.

But imaginings meant nothing, I figured I just hadn’t met the right girl yet.

Then Jack Twist didn’t know how to quit you and even if the news wasn’t turned off then, the disgust in all the reports and reviews, and the fireworks as Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal looked up, one of them running naked and leaping into a lake. It excited me.

So only a few months later when I met a boy and my heart somersaulted and my lungs caught and my stomach knotted up, and we shook hands, mine sweaty, and my knees wobbled, my breath came slow, and my blood rushed like lava in my veins, I knew then there’d never be any girl I’d wait for, and by then I finally had a word for my feelings.

Except whenever gay was on TV, either my parents turned it off or the newscasters spoke with scorn, so I didn’t tell him my feelings and I most definitely kept it all to myself.

I remember standing in bookstores, awkwardly hanging around the queer lit section, paging through gay erotica, all I knew then of LGBT culture or what I was feeling inside. But I couldn’t bring any of that home, so instead I opted for a different direction, a collection of short stories called Close Range by Annie Proulx, the last one being “Brokeback Mountain.” And I read a few of them, lying back on my father’s couch, but her writing was dense and country and didn’t have any flare for fantasy, so I shelved that book and didn’t look back–but for ten years, I kept it, pledged someday I’d finally finish it.

After that I went through a number of changes, identity crises. I tried to convince myself I was bi because it seemed like life would be easier if I could hold out for a woman, but I knew I wasn’t, and I gave it up not long thereafter. I fought myself, fought my feelings, finally had to face both of them as I found my way back to faith. Each step chipped away at me till I finally found wholeness in being a pile of dust and broken bits.

I went to Israel, came out in quarantine (that was the summer of swine flu) to defend another kid two other boys were teasing, and by the time I got out of the ward, I had been outed on campus. Not a single one of us eighty or ninety teens didn’t know I was gay. But a strange thing happened, how I knew about it: One of the guys there, he sat down next me, casually asked if I had a boyfriend back home. It was the first real glimpse of acceptance I had ever had for being gay, and it made up for his later attempts to examine my sex life in detail, if I topped or bottomed, if his collection of straight porn could get me up.

I started college, came out to my parents, not necessarily in that order, became president of our Gay-Straight Alliance, learned there was such a thing as transgender, began to gain all the confidence I’d eaten up by shunning myself all those years before. Then I graduated, transferred to a new school, made my share of mistakes, and fell in love a lot.

It was only a few months before things got spicy when, this day in 2013, the Supreme Court spoke again in United States v. Windsor. It was a victory, I remember–much like I was yesterday and today–watching the live blogging of the news, words I never could’ve imagined only a handful of years prior, before I even knew there was such a thing as blogging. And I celebrated, sure we all did, but I didn’t know (so I thought) any man I’d be marrying soon, and marriage by itself was still a pipe dream in North Carolina.

Then fate shuffled the deck, love hit hard and fast and at a distance of 1,600 miles, and I was sitting outside the library mid-November looking up federal immigration benefits for same-sex couples. And they were there now, and it became a block I built to keep going. In fact, Harel and me, we spoke about marriage before we even spoke about dating, both of us up front what we wanted in a relationship, love, life, the whole thing–and it would’ve been easy if we’d disagreed, if we had thought maybe it wasn’t worth it, but as the messages back and forth piled up, one thing was clear: we wanted all the same things.

Convincing my mother to let me fly to Mexico to meet a man I’d never met in person before was perhaps the hardest part, but thinking of him, thinking of us gave me strength and bravery I didn’t know I had, enough to ask the impossible. So then thirteen months ago, mid-April last year, we met in person, and when being together was everything and more than we could’ve imagined, we did everything short of buying rings and getting engaged.

(That, my friend, came in August.)

Which brings us around to the last twelve months, drowned in school from the day the Supreme Court let stand lower court rulings and that day in mid-October year last when North Carolina’s judges opened the floodgates of love for same-sex couples to marry. Harel and me patched together our fiance visa application one bit at a time, all my years of hoarding emails finally paying off as we compiled supporting evidence, and finally the end of February, we mailed that beast in and began the long, ongoing wait for approval.

Back in December, right up to but not including New Year’s when we we were together last, we weren’t thinking what the Supreme Court might say, what it’d make of June 26, the same days when both Lawrence and Windsor were read aloud the first times. Even six weeks ago when the summer started, I wasn’t thinking of the rulings–not immediately, at least. But three or four weeks back I read the oral arguments, set myself for waiting.

Instead I was thinking ahead, to getting married, probably next year if I had to predict, though it can’t happen soon enough, to moving out of NC up to Milwaukee where I’ve been accepted to the Teach for America corp., so naturally, I’m trying to whittle down my belongings, clear the shelves so it’s less to bring across state lines. I made a list, day after I got home, of all the books I meant to read this summer–Close Range finally in it.

And last night, after ten years of waiting, I reached the last story in the book, “Brokeback Mountain,” and as I read it I laughed, and as I read it more, I wanted to cry. I can bet Proulx never spoke to a gay man what it’s like to have sex, but she got the intimacy right, almost too right in places, like after Ennis and Jack part for the first time, not knowing what’s next:

Within a mile Ennis felt like someone was pulling his guts out hand over hand a yard at a time. He stopped at the side of the road and, in the whirling new snow, tried to puke but nothing came up. He felt about as bad as he ever had and it took a long time for the feeling to wear off. (p. 264)

I felt the same on the days I left Harel, on April 20, August 17, and December 30. Every gut-wrenching maneuver I knew, and it brought me closer to both of these boys.

Then I kept reading, closer the end, and it hit me the kind of unbridled love and intimacy Jack admired, desired, how it made him burn, and I’d quote the whole passage if it weren’t so long, but the words were too beautiful not to mention, to ignore:

What Jack remembered and craved in a way he could neither help nor understand was the time that distant summer on Brokeback Mountain when Ennis had come up behind him and pulled him close, the silent embrace satisfying some shared and sexless hunger. …

Ennis’s breath came slow and quiet, he hummed, rocked a little in the sparklight and Jack leaned against the steady heartbeat, the vibrations of the humming like faint electricity and, standing, he fell into sleep that was not sleep but something else drowsy and tranced … . (pp. 278-279)

It brought me back to all those times, in nothingness, Harel and me cleaved to each other in silence, shared and blissful, no words marring the moment, nothing left to understand but the love we held for each other, that electricity and sparklight and heartbeat vibrato.

I missed him more than I could put in words, sent him a text message right off the bat knowing full well he wouldn’t get it till morning, and I tried to sleep. I curled up in a ball, tried to recall his heat warmth and fire. My arms moved through the darkness for anything to hold to, a body, a hand, and I found my own, one hand holding the other like I was trying to pull myself up, and I thought back to the first full night he and I spent by ourselves, how the room was so hot it was unbearable to touch to sleep, how we held hands all night just to have each other before the cold air settled in and we curled up with each other.

Watching the live blogging this morning, not sure if the case would fall today or Monday, when they said “Marriage” my stomach dropped and my head got highwired and wouldn’t stop pounding until thirty minutes later when the Supreme Court moved to the next case.

Ennis and Jack, though fictional, lived back in a time when just being gay was still illegal in the United States, a time that only really ended twelve years ago with Lawrence. Even then, the thought that someday same-sex couples could get married across the country, move freely, it was a thought foreign to each of them. Jack tried to convince Ennis to move in with him, to have a ranch together, but Ennis was too full of the too-real fear that looking a bit too queer would get ’em killed, and even with marriage rights, that’s still a fear today. Maybe not as much as Jack and Ennis faced, but enough still, especially if you’re trans.

Yesterday ran into today like sweat and musk into a shirt, will pass into tomorrow just as it fades over the years, hung hidden on a nail in a closet, the last memento of lost love. But for the rest of us, for those of us still living, not imaginary but real and breathing, it’s not the end. The rights to work, to adopt, to access the healthcare we need, it’s still ongoing.

And for me and Harel, so is the wait. Because unlike Ennis and Jack, we’ve been born to a world where we can name those feelings, where we can say “I love you” without fear or shame, where we can make happen that life together that Jack so desperately wanted.

It’s still a long way off, still a spot on the horizon while we wait for the government to look at our petition and while we fundraise to afford the costs, but in just three weeks I’ll be back there, in his arms and him in mine, knowing six months apart is six months too many.

GFM sidebar


78 thoughts on “From Brokeback to Obergefell

  1. This is beautiful! I’m so glad I came across this. Thank you for sharing this lovely life experience. I wish the best for you and Harel in the future :)

    • I believe it does, and I hope it will continue to get brighter everyday. There’s still a long way to achieve full equality for all people, but I think we’re in a place to continue moving forward. Thank you for reading and commenting.

    • Thank you, K’lee, for sharing your thoughts with me. I believe there is no greater way to share gratitude with writers than to let them know their words have made a positive impact on another person, and your comment has done this for me. I’m so glad you found it as well.

    • Indeed, love is but one of many universal experiences that come to each of us similarly but in unique ways. It has always been a comfort for me to believe, even if no one can relate perfectly to every aspect of who I am, there are always points of intersection with which any two people can connect–and as our numbers grow, so do the possibilities. Thank you for commenting!

    • Thank you for such a sincere remark, but how much more beautiful would the world be if you were simply you, rather than someone else? I am certain there is a passion, a talent, a drive you possess that no one else shall ever have. Own it and be proud to be you.

    • Steve, thank you for taking the time to read my post and share your thoughts. Vulnerability is one of the scariest but amazing aspects of of humanness; there’s a poignant TED Talk on vulnerability by Brené Brown that I highly recommend. I appreciate your good wishes, and I hope the best for you as well. Thank you again.

      • I’ve only watched her TED Talks, but they were inspiring and have been so influential these past few months as I’ve struggled through some depression, and a lot of shame. My reading list is perpetually too long, but are there any particular titles of hers you would especially recommend?

  2. Pingback: chatfrom's Blog

  3. This is truly one of the few actually useful annotated notes to ‘Brokeback Mountain.’ It’s really quite the achievement to share your story like this, I bare great respect for you!

    • Thank you so much for telling me this. Until I began writing, I hadn’t realized how much the story had meant to me, or perhaps rather what it’s come to represent. If you haven’t read it, I truly feel it’s a worthy read (and can easily be enjoyed in a single day).

  4. This was absolutely beautiful, and your experience was both relatable and wonderfully honest. I grew up in the South where I was exposed to a lot of the same stuff you described…the turning off of televisions, even the disgusted utterances over Brokeback Mountain. And I, too, found and have fallen in love with a wonderful guy thousands of miles away. All the best to you, friend!

    • Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Cade. It has always amazed me how people can share such similar experiences without ever realizing they’re not the only ones. If you’d like, we can connect via Facebook or email to talk more.

  5. I thought in the west, gay and lesbian citizens where really accepted as normal, atleast now. How does the society see you? Are there people who look at you with some dislike? Anyway, I see you’ve put your heart in this post.

    • Hi Nihal! You ask some interesting questions, which my own individual experiences will not adequately answer. For the most part, my immediate friends do not see being LGBT as anything unusual, perhaps not common, but certainly not wrong. However, I’ve also chosen to align myself with those communities that are most accepting. There are many who do not have the ability to do this, who have families that do not welcome and support them, nor live in neighborhoods hostile to people who are LGBT. I can recall many times seeing protestors at Pride events, or hearing the parents of friends make remarks such as Hurricane Katrina (and other natural disasters) being the fault of gays. So, yes, it’s a mixed bag of support and opposition, but I think that’s everywhere to varying degrees.

      • I’m from India. You might know in my place theres a lot of opposition. There are supporters too. I don’t have much say about it being right or wrong but I’m certainly against being hostile towards LGBT or any group following certain ideologies.

      • I’m ashamed to say I’m fairly ignorant of the state of LGBT equality in the world outside the United States. I would love to learn more and be a global advocate, but I’m also wary of rushing in and demanding things be the same as they are here when cultures and customs vary so widely, of which I know so little. I believe in my heart equality of this sort is necessary and will be achieved in all places, but the paths that lead each country to that end cannot be the same because no two countries are the same. If you happen to know of a good place to learn more about India’s fight for LGBT rights, and especially how allies in the U.S. can lend a hand, please point me in that direction.

    • Thank you so much, Bradley. If you’re able to support our GoFundMe campaign (linked at the bottom), we would be grateful either for a contribution or simply sharing the link on social media. Thank you again for reading and sharing your kind remarks.

  6. This was heartbreaking and utterly beautiful. If every person that opposes same-sex marriage could read this with an open mind and- more importantly- an open heart, I think it could make a world of difference. I wish the best for both of you. Thank you for sharing your story because I know digging up old memories can be painful. You have a gift.

    • Renee, your words have made a new warmth stir inside me; thank you for your kindness, your compassion, and for taking the time to read my story and share your thoughts. I wish you the best as well.

  7. My goodness! This almost made me cry. And considering the fact that I’m not a guy that cries easily(actually I hadn’t had the slightest urge to cry since I bawled my eyes out when my grandad died), that means a lot.

    Firstly, I must say that I’m deeply moved by your struggles with your sexual orientation and that I sympathize with you when you mention the “scornful newscasters” that castigated gay relationships. Honestly, I’m fairly new to this ideology, but I can empathize with your needs to be with someone you love and care. Trying to force yourself, to convince yourself that you’re bi might not be possible to change your in-bred homosexuality. So I guess it must be a very heartening moment when the Supreme Court announced its final decision on the 26th. Although all those years of hardship and all those criticism and castigation given to you by hypocritical straight people might not end, but at least now you have the freedom to marry whom you truly love, and not to marry the one whom society has pre-dictated for you. For this, I give you my heartfelt congratulations.

    Anyway, after seeing all the discriminating comments towards the Supreme Court’s ruling, I wrote an article about it to express my disagreement. As I said, I’m fairly new to this subject, and I would sincerely appreciate some honest and truthful feedback from a friend (can I call you so? It sounds, err, friendlier haha) like you. So here you go:

    Peace. :)

    • Steven, I am moved beyond words by your kind remarks, and I’m not sure where I would even begin to say thank you for everything you’ve shared. I will make an effort to read your post as soon as I can; I’ve been traveling lately with family and have had limited time to read or write because of it. I will be sure to share my thoughts when I do. Once again, thank you for your uplifting comments.

      • You are absolutely welcome! And good luck for all the travails and life!

        PS: have fun traveling! :D

  8. Thanks for sharing your struggle! As a follower of G-d and a citizen, I truly am sorry for your pain! If only our nation believed in the phrase ” inalienable rights”! The state does not give us our rights, we already posses them as a gift of G-d! We must admit that we have a motive conflict: we want validity and legitimacy of the state which is Constituionally restrained from adding to our subtracting from our INALIENABLE RIGHTS!

    • Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us. I believe, as a whole, our society will move towards a more equitable end, but to get there we must speak openly and also be proud and accepting of our own vulnerability. Looking back, I did go through painful times, but they have shaped me into the caring and gentle advocate I’ve become, and I wouldn’t change my past for anything. Thank you again.

  9. Lucky are those who find love to live with.. Your post describes a lot about not understanding feelings which you have never heard of, which is the case with almost many of our feelings.. It was a beautiful post..

  10. My best friend is gay. His struggle is similar to yours. He has welled up after reading your story. Thank you for making him feel like he’s not the only one, I never could. And thank you, for making it clearer to me, how he must fight with himself to accept his own self. Thank you so much sir. God bless you

    • It is such an honor to receive a comment like this. Thank you so much for sharing this with your friend, and for sharing this part of both of you with me. I wish you both the best.

Join the Conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s